Does Solar Raise Electricity Prices? What New MIT Research Means for Energy Customers

New research challenges assumptions about renewable energy costs, revealing important differences between utility-scale solar and residential rooftop solar.

As electricity prices continue to concern homeowners, businesses, and policymakers, one question frequently emerges: Does expanding solar energy make electricity more expensive?

New research from the MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research suggests the answer is more complicated than a simple yes or no.

In Episode 63 of The Solar Coaster Podcast, Anna Covert and Alex Herrera explore research examining how renewable energy policies, utility-scale solar generation, and rooftop solar adoption relate to residential electricity prices.

The findings offer important insights into the economics of solar energy and the design of America’s electrical grid.

What Does the Research Show?

The researchers studied electricity prices, renewable energy generation, utility expenditures, and renewable portfolio standards across U.S. states and utilities between 1998 and 2023.

The analysis found that utility-scale renewable generation was not associated with higher residential electricity prices. Utility-scale solar, in particular, was strongly associated with lower prices.

Rooftop solar showed a different pattern, with higher rooftop solar penetration associated with higher residential electricity prices and increased distribution operation and maintenance costs.

These findings represent correlations rather than proof that either type of solar directly causes electricity prices to rise or fall.

Utility-Scale Solar May Support Electricity Affordability

One of the most significant findings concerns large solar power plants.

According to the study’s regression estimates, a ten-percentage-point increase in utility-scale solar’s share of electricity generation was associated with residential electricity prices just over 8% lower.

This relationship does not guarantee that every utility-scale solar installation will produce a corresponding reduction in electricity rates.

However, it challenges the idea that adding large amounts of renewable generation necessarily makes power more expensive.

Why Could Large Solar Projects Help?

Utility-scale solar facilities offer several potential economic advantages.

  • No ongoing fuel purchases: Solar facilities generate electricity without purchasing coal, natural gas, or oil as fuel.
  • Predictable generation economics: Solar projects can provide greater visibility into certain long-term operating costs.
  • Potential congestion benefits: Depending on location and grid conditions, new generation can help relieve constraints within the electricity system.
  • Large-scale generation: Utility-scale projects can supply significant electricity volumes through the bulk power system.
  • Energy diversification: Solar can contribute to a broader generation portfolio and reduce exposure to certain fuel-market risks.

These benefits depend on project location, interconnection requirements, financing, transmission access, and overall system integration.

Solar power plants still require substantial upfront investment, ongoing maintenance, and appropriate infrastructure.

Why Does Rooftop Solar Have a Different Relationship With Electricity Rates?

The MIT researchers found that a five-percentage-point increase in rooftop solar’s share was associated with residential electricity prices approximately 16% higher.

It is important not to interpret this result as proof that installing rooftop solar directly increases electricity prices.

Areas with expensive electricity may naturally attract more rooftop solar customers seeking relief from high utility bills.

Local regulations, compensation policies, infrastructure investments, and customer behavior may also influence the relationship.

Nevertheless, the findings highlight a fundamental challenge in electricity pricing: how utilities recover the costs of infrastructure shared by all customers.

Understanding Grid Costs and Solar Cost Shifting

Electric utilities maintain extensive infrastructure to deliver reliable power.

Even when a homeowner installs solar panels, the property may still depend on the grid for electricity at night, during cloudy weather, or whenever solar production does not meet demand.

Maintaining that connection requires distribution equipment, maintenance, billing systems, operational controls, and grid reliability investments.

Traditional electricity rates frequently recover a portion of these expenses through charges based on how many kilowatt-hours customers purchase.

When rooftop solar reduces those purchases, the utility may collect less revenue through volumetric charges, even though many shared infrastructure costs remain.

Depending on the applicable rate structure, this can shift a portion of shared costs toward customers without rooftop solar.

However, distributed solar may also create system benefits. A comprehensive evaluation must consider avoided energy costs, the timing of solar production, local grid conditions, and potential infrastructure savings.

Utility-Scale Solar and Rooftop Solar Serve Different Roles

Both technologies convert sunlight into electricity, but their relationships with the electrical grid are different.

Utility-Scale Solar

Large solar facilities are generally developed as centralized generation resources connected to the bulk power system.

Their generation is integrated into broader utility and grid-operator planning processes.

These projects may serve utilities, businesses, and other electricity purchasers through long-term contractual arrangements.

Rooftop Solar

Residential rooftop systems generate electricity at individual customer properties.

They can reduce electricity purchases from the utility and may export excess generation onto local distribution circuits.

Those exports can create new requirements for distribution system planning, voltage management, protection equipment, and bidirectional electricity flows.

At the same time, rooftop solar can provide value when its generation aligns with local demand or helps reduce specific system costs.

Understanding these differences is essential when comparing solar economics.

What Does the Research Say About Renewable Energy Mandates?

Renewable portfolio standards require or encourage electricity providers to source a portion of their electricity from renewable resources.

Critics sometimes argue that these policies inevitably increase electricity rates.

The MIT analysis found that renewable portfolio standard stringency had virtually zero association with residential electricity prices.

This does not mean every renewable energy requirement is equally effective or that implementation costs never matter.

It does suggest that renewable energy policy and electricity affordability are not necessarily in conflict.

Why California’s Rooftop Solar Debate Matters

California has become a focal point for disagreements over rooftop solar compensation and electricity rate design.

Some analyses estimate significant cost shifting from rooftop solar customers to other utility ratepayers.

Other studies identify substantial benefits associated with distributed solar generation.

These competing findings demonstrate the importance of evaluating the assumptions behind cost-benefit calculations.

Differences in avoided energy costs, infrastructure requirements, environmental benefits, time horizons, and customer compensation can substantially change the results.

For the broader solar industry, California illustrates why transparent electricity pricing and sound grid planning matter.

What Does This Mean for Commercial and Utility-Scale Solar Development?

The findings reinforce the importance of evaluating solar projects within the larger energy system.

For commercial energy customers and utility-scale developers, project economics should account for more than equipment pricing alone.

Important considerations include:

  • Long-term electricity cost exposure and rate structures
  • Project location and interconnection requirements
  • Expected energy production and operating expenses
  • Utility tariffs and power purchase arrangements
  • Transmission and distribution infrastructure
  • Applicable incentives and regulatory requirements
  • System reliability and operational performance

A properly designed solar project can contribute to long-term energy planning, but the financial outcome depends on the customer’s circumstances and the project’s structure.

Why the Findings Should Be Interpreted Carefully

The MIT research is a working paper rather than a final determination of cause and effect.

The researchers acknowledge that their findings are correlations and that additional analysis is needed to establish stronger causal conclusions.

Electricity prices depend on numerous factors, including fuel costs, infrastructure spending, regulatory decisions, utility operations, and customer demand.

Solar adoption and electricity rates can also influence each other.

For example, high electricity prices may encourage more homeowners to install rooftop solar. This makes it difficult to determine whether solar adoption contributes to higher rates, higher rates encourage solar adoption, or both are influenced by additional factors.

Recognizing these distinctions is essential for responsible energy policy and investment decisions.

The Future of Solar and Electricity Affordability

The research highlights an important opportunity: expanding renewable energy and maintaining affordable electricity do not have to be competing goals.

Utility-scale solar may contribute to lower generation costs, while distributed solar can provide customer-level benefits when properly integrated and valued.

The challenge is designing electricity systems that account for actual costs, recognize the benefits of different energy resources, and distribute shared infrastructure expenses fairly.

As the energy industry evolves, successful solar development will require thoughtful engineering, transparent economics, and effective coordination among developers, utilities, regulators, and customers.

Explore Solar Energy Solutions With Sun Energy Today

At Sun Energy Today, we believe informed energy decisions begin with understanding the technology, economics, and long-term goals behind each project.

Whether you’re evaluating commercial solar or exploring opportunities in utility-scale renewable energy, understanding the relationship between generation costs and electricity rates is an important part of the process.

Explore our solar energy services:

Listen to The Solar Coaster Podcast — Episode 63

For a deeper discussion of the MIT findings, join Anna Covert and Alex Herrera on Episode 63 of The Solar Coaster Podcast.

They examine the research, explain the differences between rooftop and utility-scale solar, and discuss the implications for electricity pricing and clean energy policy.

Watch: The Solar Coaster on YouTube

Explore the podcast: The Solar Coaster Podcast

This article discusses research findings and their potential implications. The statistical associations described should not be interpreted as proof of causation or as guaranteed outcomes for individual solar projects.

Episode 63 Transcript: Does Solar Raise Electricity Prices?

The Solar Coaster Podcast, presented by Sun Energy Today — Featuring Anna Covert and Alex Herrera

Anna Covert: Today we are unpacking a finding that sounds simple at first, but gets more interesting the longer you sit with it: in the United States, utility-scale solar appears to be associated with lower residential electricity prices, while rooftop solar appears to be associated with higher residential electricity prices. That is the headline from recent research by Fischer J. Espiritu Argosino and Christopher R. Knittel at the MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research. Their work looks across states, utilities, and years, connecting residential power prices with renewable portfolio standards, generation mixes, and utility spending. And the big takeaway is not that renewables automatically make bills higher. In fact, the researchers found that renewable portfolio standards had virtually zero impact on prices, and utility-scale renewables were not linked with higher residential prices.

Alex Herrera: That is important because the public conversation often collapses very different things into one bucket called renewables. A large solar plant connected to the bulk power system is not the same thing as a solar array on a customer's roof. A state renewable portfolio standard is not the same thing as a utility's spending on distribution infrastructure. And a correlation in a working paper is not the same thing as a final causal verdict. So today, we will slow this down. We will talk through what the study actually measured, what it suggests, where it is cautious, and why rooftop solar remains such a contentious topic in places like California. The aim is not to pick a side, but to understand why electricity affordability depends so much on system design, rate design, and cost recovery.

Anna Covert: Let's start with the research design in plain English. The MIT researchers built what they describe as a state-utility panel covering the years from 1998 to 2023. That means they were comparing data over time, across states and utilities, rather than just looking at one year or one region. They linked residential electricity prices with renewable portfolio standard stringency, the mix of electricity generation, and utility spending. The data sources included the Energy Information Administration, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. So this is not a small anecdotal comparison of a few utilities. It is an attempt to use a broad set of data to ask whether policies and technologies are moving prices up or down.

Alex Herrera: And they used a two way fixed effects regression model. That phrase can sound intimidating, but the basic purpose is straightforward. The model tries to control for unobserved differences across years and between states. In other words, it tries to avoid confusing broad time trends or state-specific characteristics with the effect being studied. If one state has always had expensive electricity for reasons unrelated to renewables, the model should not simply blame renewables for that. If one year had nationwide price pressure, the model should account for that too. The researchers' summary says that, using this model, renewable portfolio standards and utility-scale renewables are not associated with higher residential electricity prices. Utility-scale renewables are modestly associated with lower prices, and utility-scale solar is strongly linked with lower prices.

Anna Covert: The numbers are striking. Based on the paper's regression coefficients, which measure generation shares relative to coal, a ten percentage point rise in utility-scale solar's share of generation is associated with residential electricity prices just over eight percent lower. That does not mean a solar plant automatically causes an eight percent reduction in every customer's bill. The authors themselves caution that the results are correlations. But it is still a notable association, especially because it cuts against the claim that more large-scale solar necessarily means higher household electricity prices. The researchers offer one possible explanation: large solar plants may reduce network congestion and place downward pressure on overall generation costs because they do not require fuel inputs.

Alex Herrera: That fuel point matters. A solar plant does not need coal, gas, or oil delivered every day in order to produce electricity. Once it is built, the sunlight is not purchased in a commodity market. Of course, there are capital costs, interconnection issues, maintenance costs, and system integration needs. But the absence of fuel inputs can affect generation costs and price dynamics. The researchers also ran a second model that controlled for differences between utilities, and in that model, utility-scale solar was strongly associated with lower transmission, distribution, and total operation and maintenance costs. Again, the key word is associated. Still, the pattern is interesting: at least in this analysis, large-scale solar is not showing up as a driver of higher residential prices.

Anna Covert: Now contrast that with the rooftop solar result. The researchers found that a five percentage point rise in rooftop solar's share is associated with residential prices roughly sixteen percent higher. That is a much larger association, and it immediately raises a question: does rooftop solar make electricity more expensive, or is rooftop solar more common in places where electricity is already expensive, or are both things tied to deeper utility and policy structures? The authors are careful here. They say further work will apply more rigorous econometric techniques to strengthen the causal interpretation of the estimates. That is an important caveat. We should not overstate what a correlation can prove. But we also should not ignore the pattern, because it connects directly to a very real policy debate.

Alex Herrera: The debate is about cost shifting. The researchers suggest that tariff design may partly explain the rooftop solar result. In some states, current rate structures may shift fixed costs associated with rooftop solar from owners onto other ratepayers. Put simply, utilities have costs that do not disappear just because some customers produce part of their own electricity. Distribution networks, billing systems, maintenance, grid readiness, and other fixed or semi-fixed costs still need to be paid for. If rooftop solar customers reduce the amount of electricity they buy from the grid, and if rates recover many fixed costs through volumetric charges, then customers without rooftop solar may end up carrying more of those costs through higher per-kilowatt-hour rates.

Anna Covert: That does not mean every rooftop solar customer is doing something wrong. Many people install solar because they want lower bills, cleaner energy, more control, or resilience. And policies in many states have encouraged them to do exactly that. The issue is not personal blame; it is rate structure. If the rules are designed in a way that rewards one kind of behavior while leaving shared grid costs to be recovered from everyone else, then the distribution of costs becomes controversial. The researchers phrase it carefully: in effect, those without rooftop solar often fund those who do through an additional volumetric rate. That is a powerful sentence because it turns an engineering question into an equity question.

Alex Herrera: There is also a physical grid issue. Rooftop solar was strongly correlated with higher distribution operation and maintenance costs. The researchers point to one possible reason: the distribution network was not designed for bidirectional power flows. Traditionally, electricity flowed from large generators through transmission lines, into distribution networks, and then to homes and businesses. Rooftop solar changes that pattern. At times, power can flow from homes back onto local circuits. That can be valuable, but it can also require upgrades, controls, planning, and operational changes. So even when rooftop solar reduces some demand from the grid, it can create new needs on the distribution system.

Anna Covert: This is where the conversation becomes more nuanced than solar good or solar bad. Utility-scale solar and rooftop solar both use photovoltaic technology, but they interact with the grid differently. A large solar project is usually planned, interconnected, and operated as part of the bulk power system. Its output is visible to grid operators and integrated into system planning. Rooftop solar is distributed across many customer sites. It can reduce purchases from the grid at certain times, but it may not reduce the need for the local grid to serve that customer when the sun is down, when demand peaks, or when weather conditions change. The economic value depends on timing, location, rates, and avoided costs.

Alex Herrera: And the study's finding on renewable portfolio standards deserves attention too. Renewable portfolio standards, or RPS policies, require or encourage electricity suppliers to obtain a certain share of power from renewable sources. Critics sometimes argue that these policies raise electricity prices. But in this MIT working paper, RPS stringency had virtually zero impact on residential prices. That does not mean every policy design is perfect or that all compliance costs are irrelevant. It means that, in this broad analysis, RPS policies themselves were not associated with higher residential electricity prices. That is consistent with the wider point that the relationship between clean energy policy and affordability is not automatic. It depends on implementation, market conditions, and system costs.

Anna Covert: There is another study mentioned in the same discussion that points in a similar direction for utility-scale renewables. A June 2025 study from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, led by Ryan Wiser, found that roughly seventy-five percent of utility-scale wind and solar built outside RPS programs had no broadly discernible upward effect on retail prices. That is not identical to the MIT analysis, but it reinforces a similar theme: the growth of utility-scale wind and solar is not clearly showing up as a broad driver of higher retail electricity prices. For policymakers, that matters because electricity affordability is one of the central concerns in energy transition debates.

Alex Herrera: Now, California is the place where this gets especially heated. The rooftop solar finding feeds into a long-running dispute over cost shifting there. The California Public Utilities Commission's Public Advocates Office has estimated an eight point five billion dollar cost shift from rooftop solar customers to other ratepayers. That is a very large number, and it has been used to argue that compensation structures for rooftop solar need reform. But there is also a competing analysis. A 2025 report by M.Cubed Consulting and the California Solar and Storage Association found that rooftop solar delivered a one point five billion dollar net benefit to all California ratepayers. So even within one state, the measurement of costs and benefits is contested.

Anna Covert: That disagreement tells us something important: the answer often depends on what you count, how you count it, and over what time horizon. Do you focus on avoided energy costs, avoided capacity needs, environmental benefits, transmission deferral, distribution costs, or customer bill impacts? Do you measure benefits to the individual solar customer, to non-solar customers, to the utility system, or to society more broadly? Different studies can produce different results because they draw the boundary around the problem differently. The MIT working paper does not settle every one of those disputes. But it adds a broad empirical finding: rooftop solar penetration is correlated with higher residential prices, while utility-scale solar penetration is correlated with lower residential prices.

Alex Herrera: Solar advocates have also argued that rising transmission and distribution spending is a larger driver of rate increases. That point should not be brushed aside. Even if rooftop solar is associated with higher distribution operation and maintenance costs in the MIT analysis, transmission and distribution spending can rise for many reasons: aging infrastructure, wildfire mitigation in some regions, storm hardening, load growth, interconnection needs, and broader grid modernization. The research summary does not say rooftop solar is the only driver of higher rates. It says rooftop solar is strongly correlated with higher distribution operation and maintenance costs and higher residential prices. That is meaningful, but it is not the entire electricity bill story.

Anna Covert: Let's talk about what policymakers might take from this. The researchers conclude that policymakers can secure an affordable energy future by improving the integration of low-cost renewables while implementing more equitable cost recovery strategies. That sentence carries two ideas at once. First, low-cost renewables can be part of an affordability strategy, especially if utility-scale solar is placing downward pressure on generation costs. Second, affordability also requires fair ways to pay for the grid. If fixed costs are recovered mainly through volumetric electricity rates, then customers who consume fewer kilowatt-hours from the grid may contribute less to shared costs, even if they still rely on the grid for backup, exports, or reliability.

Alex Herrera: There are many possible ways to address that, though the material we are discussing does not prescribe one detailed solution. Utilities and regulators can rethink tariff design, cost allocation, export compensation, and the balance between fixed and variable charges. They can also improve planning for distributed energy resources so that rooftop solar is integrated where it provides the most value and with fewer distribution challenges. The central point is that price signals matter. If rates do not reflect the real costs and benefits of different resources at different times and places, then the system can produce outcomes that feel unfair or inefficient. The affordability question is not just what technology we build, but how we price and manage it.

Anna Covert: It is also worth emphasizing the status of the MIT paper. The Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research does not peer-review working papers before posting them. That does not mean the work is wrong. Working papers are a normal part of academic research, and they often share important findings before journal review. But it does mean listeners should treat the results as part of an evolving evidence base. The authors themselves are cautious and say they plan further work using more rigorous econometric techniques to strengthen causal interpretation. So the responsible reading is: this is a serious analysis with provocative findings, but it should not be treated as the final word on causality.

Alex Herrera: That caution is especially important because energy systems are full of feedback loops. High electricity prices can encourage rooftop solar adoption. Rooftop solar adoption can affect utility revenue collection. Changes in utility revenue collection can affect rates. Higher rates can encourage more rooftop solar adoption. Meanwhile, regulators may adjust compensation rules, utilities may change spending plans, and customers may add storage or shift consumption. A simple cause-and-effect story can miss that circular dynamic. That is why the study's distinction between correlation and causation matters so much. It allows us to see the pattern without pretending that every mechanism has been fully proven.

Anna Covert: Still, the practical implications are significant. If utility-scale solar is strongly linked with lower residential prices, then policymakers who are worried about affordability may want to pay close attention to barriers facing large solar projects. Those barriers might include interconnection, siting, permitting, transmission access, or market integration, though the study summary specifically highlights the possible role of reduced congestion and no fuel inputs. At the same time, if rooftop solar is linked with higher residential prices and distribution costs, then policymakers may want to revisit compensation and grid cost recovery, not necessarily to punish rooftop solar, but to make sure the system remains fair for customers who cannot install it.

Alex Herrera: That fairness point matters because not every household has the same ability to adopt rooftop solar. Some people rent. Some live in apartments. Some have shaded roofs. Some cannot access financing. Some may move before an investment pays back. If a rate structure provides strong benefits to rooftop solar owners while shifting costs to nonparticipants, then affordability concerns can become distributional concerns. On the other hand, if rooftop solar provides system-wide value, policies should recognize that too. The challenge is designing tariffs that are neither blindly generous nor unfairly punitive. The research pushes us toward more careful accounting, not toward slogans.

Anna Covert: Another useful takeaway is that the location of solar matters. Utility-scale solar may reduce overall generation costs, but that does not automatically mean every solar project has the same value in every location. Rooftop solar may create distribution challenges, but that does not mean every rooftop system creates the same costs. A system on a constrained feeder at a time of low local demand may have different impacts than a system that helps serve local load when it is needed. The MIT analysis operates at a broad statistical level, so it can reveal large patterns. But real-world implementation still requires local planning.

Alex Herrera: And then there is the language of affordability itself. Residential electricity prices are not the same as total household energy burden. A household's bill depends on the rate, consumption, weather, efficiency, building quality, and appliance use. The MIT paper focuses on residential electricity prices, and that is a crucial metric. But for families, affordability is experienced as the bill that arrives each month. If rates rise but usage falls, the bill effect may be different. If rates fall but consumption rises, the bill effect may also be different. So this study gives us one essential piece of the affordability puzzle, while the full customer experience remains broader.

Anna Covert: What I find most valuable about the research is that it separates three often-confused claims. Claim one: renewable portfolio standards raise residential prices. In this analysis, they do not appear to. Claim two: utility-scale renewables raise residential prices. In this analysis, they do not appear to, and utility-scale solar is linked with lower prices. Claim three: rooftop solar affects rates in ways that may increase prices for other customers. In this analysis, rooftop solar is associated with higher prices and higher distribution operation and maintenance costs. Those are different claims, and treating them separately leads to a much more productive conversation.

Alex Herrera: Exactly. The energy transition is not one policy, one technology, or one bill impact. It is a set of choices about generation, infrastructure, incentives, and fairness. The evidence described here suggests that large-scale renewables can be compatible with affordability, and perhaps even supportive of it, while distributed rooftop solar raises more complicated questions about distribution grids and cost recovery. That does not make rooftop solar a villain. It makes tariff design and grid integration central. If policymakers want clean energy and affordable bills, they need to align incentives with real system value and make sure shared costs are recovered equitably.

Anna Covert: So the bottom line is this: the MIT researchers found no link between renewable portfolio standards or utility-scale wind and solar and higher U.S. residential power prices. They found utility-scale solar strongly associated with lower prices. They also found rooftop solar associated with higher prices and higher distribution operation and maintenance costs. But they caution that these are correlations, and further work is needed to strengthen causal interpretation. For listeners, the lesson is to be precise. Ask what kind of solar we are talking about. Ask how costs are recovered. Ask whether the grid was designed for the flows being asked of it. And ask who pays when the rules change.

Alex Herrera: That precision may be the difference between a shouting match and a useful policy conversation. If the goal is an affordable energy future, the research points toward integrating low-cost renewables well and designing fairer cost recovery strategies. Large solar plants, rooftop systems, distribution networks, and customer rates all interact. The challenge is to make those interactions visible, measured, and equitable. The clean energy debate is often framed as a fight between climate goals and affordability. This evidence suggests the better question is not whether renewables raise prices, but which renewables, under which rate structures, connected to which parts of the grid, and paid for by whom.

This transcript reproduces the supplied Episode 63 dialogue. The MIT working paper reports statistical associations, not established causal effects.

Explore Solar Energy With Sun Energy Today

Learn more about Sun Energy Today and renewable energy opportunities.

Commercial Solar Solutions

Utility-Scale Solar Development

Explore Solar Projects

Get Started With Sun Energy Today

Listen to The Solar Coaster Podcast

Join Anna Covert and Alex Herrera for more discussions about solar energy, electricity markets, renewable technology, and the future of clean energy.

Visit The Solar Coaster Podcast

Watch The Solar Coaster on YouTube